Kathmandu. Various media outlets have been continuously publishing reports claiming that two mobile phones seized from Inam Sapkota, who was arrested on money laundering charges, were kept at the private residence of Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s chief advisor, Kumar Ben, for two days prior to forensic examination. As back-to-back reports regarding Ben’s involvement and alleged tampering with evidence surfaced in mainstream media, national politics has become sharply polarized. While this incident has raised serious legal questions regarding the rule of law and the impartiality of investigations, it has also brought public distrust toward state mechanisms and the debate over the Prime Minister's direct oversight to the forefront.

Legal and Procedural Questions: Keeping Evidence at a Private Residence is Illegal

According to legal and security experts, taking any digital or physical evidence seized during a criminal investigation outside the police’s official "chain of custody" (control system) is clearly an illegal act. According to details of the forensic examination report published in the media, it has been claimed that the mobile phone was confirmed to be in the area of Ben’s residence in Jwagal, Lalitpur, on the night of October 2.

Critics argue that unauthorized possession of the mobile phone at a private residence before sending it to the police forensic laboratory, accessing social media (WhatsApp and Facebook) on it, taking screenshots, and deleting certain messages have severely compromised the credibility of the investigation. Based on these media reports, opposition parties and civil society are demanding an impartial probe, stating that a person holding a responsible position like the Prime Minister's advisor taking control of investigative materials without legal authority constitutes an abuse of power and an attempt to destroy evidence.

The Other Side of Public Sentiment: Distrust of Police Mechanisms and Expectations from Balen

As complex as the legal aspect of this incident is, the other side of the issue is being equally debated in social and political circles. The bitter experience of Nepal Police and traditional state investigative agencies failing to conduct impartial probes in past major corruption and crime scandals, and hiding evidence under political pressure, remains fresh among the general public.

For this reason, deep distrust toward the police investigation process is visible among a section of society. According to supporters, relying on old mechanisms carries the risk of letting "big fish" escape and covering up collusion with powerful individuals. Therefore, public sentiment is also growing stronger that Prime Minister Balendra Shah himself and his trusted team must exercise direct oversight and intervene in every major and sensitive investigation in the country. Viewed from this perspective, although Ben’s move appears procedurally flawed, it is also being interpreted as an intentional step taken to bring out the truth and break the "setting" within the system.

What Will Balen’s Possible Political Reaction Be if the 'Lakshman Rekha' is Crossed?

Baluwatar is closely monitoring the news reports and all-round attacks coming out in various media outlets against Kumar Ben, who is known in Nepali politics as the chief strategist or "Chanakya" of Prime Minister Balen Shah. According to political analysts, if the Balen camp perceives this media and political siege against Ben not merely as a legal inquiry, but as a premeditated "political attack" aimed at making the government fail, the situation could take a new turn.

Various speculations are currently underway regarding what Balen Shah’s reaction would be if he feels the political attack has crossed the "Lakshman Rekha":

Aggressive Counterattack

Whether while leading the metropolis in the past or in political maneuvers, Balen has always adopted an aggressive style rather than becoming defensive whenever his team and agenda are attacked. If he feels the attack on Ben has crossed the limit, there is a strong possibility that Balen will go directly to the public and launch a fierce counterattack against old political forces and mechanisms.

Disclosure of Confidential Information

A silence has fallen over political circles as details of conversations with high-ranking officials, businessmen, and judges from Inam Sapkota’s mobile phone have begun to surface. Analysts believe that if Ben is targeted further, the Balen faction could use those sensitive pieces of information and corruption files as weapons to put opponents in a moral crisis.

Test of the Rule of Law

On the other hand, having risen to power on the slogans of good governance and transparency, Balen faces equal moral pressure as his own chief advisor is dragged into controversy. Therefore, while countering the political attack, whether he chooses the path of protecting his moral high ground by paving the way for an investigation or puts his full strength into defending his "Chanakya" will be determined by upcoming political developments.